AEW All In has quickly become the promotion’s biggest annual event. From its independent roots in 2018 to blockbuster stadium shows in London and Texas, every All In main event has played a part in shaping AEW’s history.
That’s why we’ve ranked every AEW All In main event from 2018 through 2025. Each main event represents a different chapter in AEW’s journey, from the grassroots feel of All In 2018 to the massive stadium spectacles that followed.
4. Cody Rhodes vs. Nick Aldis (All In 2018)
NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship | Sears Centre, Hoffman Estates, Illinois
Even though the Golden Elite six-man tag officially closed All In 2018, many fans still see Cody Rhodes vs. Nick Aldis as the real main event of the show. For Cody, this was more than just a title match. His father, Dusty Rhodes, was a three-time NWA World Heavyweight Champion, so winning that same championship meant a lot to him. That personal story made this match the most emotional moment of the night.
When Cody defeated Nick Aldis to win the title, it became much more than a championship victory. Seeing him celebrate with the belt in front of a sold-out crowd gave fans a moment they still remember today. Many people believe this show gave Tony Khan and the wrestling world the confidence that a major wrestling promotion could succeed outside of WWE. This match is ranked fourth only because the six-man tag officially ended the show, not because it was less important. In terms of history, it was one of the biggest moments that helped lead to the creation of AEW.
Why it matters today: Every story about AEW’s history eventually comes back to this match. It was the moment that showed what was possible and helped start the journey that led to AEW
3. Bryan Danielson vs. Swerve Strickland (All In 2024)
AEW World Championship | Wembley Stadium, London
AEW had a big challenge going into its second All In at Wembley because the 2023 event had already set the bar very high. This time, the company told a different kind of story. Bryan Danielson had already said that this could be his final run for the AEW World Championship, so the match felt like an important moment in his career, not just another title match. On the other side was Swerve Strickland, who had become one of AEW’s strongest heel champions. He was the perfect opponent to test whether Danielson could win one more world title.
Danielson won the championship in a match that had everything fans wanted. It mixed great technical wrestling with real emotion, and every big moment felt important. The rest of the show also helped make the night special, with surprise returns and a major debut that kept fans excited from the opening match to the final bell. That is why All In 2024 is remembered as one of AEW’s best events.
Why it matters today: This match is frequently cited by fans as proof that AEW can build a retirement-style story with real emotional payoff, similar to how WWE has handled its own legend send-offs.
2. MJF vs. Adam Cole (All In 2023)
AEW World Championship | Wembley Stadium, London
The first Wembley show carried an almost impossible amount of pressure. Over 80,000 fans packed into the stadium for what was billed as the biggest wrestling event in company history, and the main event between best friends MJF and Adam Cole had to deliver both a five-star match and a satisfying resolution to their real-life friendship storyline.
The match itself told a story of loyalty being tested under the brightest lights possible. Roderick Strong’s interference, Cole’s refusal to use the title belt as a weapon, and the eventual hug between the two men after MJF retained closed the show on an emotional high rather than a shock twist. It remains one of the most complete “friendship vs. business” stories AEW has told.
Why it matters today: The image of two friends embracing in front of a sold-out Wembley crowd is still one of the most replayed AEW moments online, and it set the standard for what an All In main event should feel like.
1. Hangman Page vs. Jon Moxley (All In 2025)
AEW World Championship | Globe Life Field, Arlington, Texas
Moving All In to Texas was more than just a change of location for AEW. It was a statement, and the main event had to prove that the show could succeed outside of London. Hangman Page vs. Jon Moxley did exactly that. Hangman’s journey to win back the AEW World Championship had been building for years, and this match felt like the biggest chapter in that story. The closing moments brought several of AEW’s top stars into the action, creating a chaotic and unpredictable finish where it felt like the match could go in any direction.
When Hangman Page finally regained the AEW World Championship in front of a record crowd, it became one of the most emotional moments in AEW history. Few title victories have given fans that kind of feel-good ending since Cody Rhodes won the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship at All In 2018. That is why this match takes the top spot in these rankings. It delivered the emotional payoff of a story that had been years in the making, while also giving fans a star-filled, action-packed main event that kept everyone guessing until the final bell.
Why it matters today: This match proved All In can succeed outside of Wembley, and it gave AEW a new benchmark for how a world title match can feel like a true company-wide event rather than a two-man story.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is AEW All In? AEW All In is the company’s biggest annual event. It began as an independent show in 2018 before becoming AEW’s flagship pay-per-view in 2023, with recent editions taking place in major stadiums.
Which All In had the biggest attendance? All In 2023 at Wembley Stadium drew over 80,000 fans, making it the largest paid attendance for a professional wrestling event in modern history at the time.
Who has main evented All In the most? No wrestler has headlined more than one All In main event as of 2025, though Toni Khan has built each edition around a different top star, from Cody Rhodes to Hangman Page.
Is All In AEW’s biggest pay-per-view? Yes. All In consistently draws the largest crowds and biggest match cards of any AEW event, making it the promotion’s equivalent of a marquee, once-a-year showcase.
Final Thoughts
When you look back at every AEW All In main event, one thing becomes clear: every edition has told a different story. All In 2018 showed that an independent wrestling event could help change the industry. In 2023, Wembley Stadium turned a story about friendship and loyalty into one of AEW’s most memorable world title matches. Bryan Danielson’s emotional championship win in 2024 felt like the perfect chapter in his legendary career, while 2025 took All In to another level with Hangman Page’s long-awaited redemption story.
That is what makes All In AEW’s biggest annual event. Instead of following the same formula every year, each main event has reflected where the company was at that point in its journey. Some helped build AEW’s identity, some celebrated major milestones, and others opened the door to a new chapter. As AEW moves toward future editions of All In, the expectations will only get higher. Every new main event will be judged not only against the previous year’s match but also against the moments that helped shape AEW’s history.
This ranking is based on the historical impact, storytelling, match quality, and lasting legacy of every AEW All In main event through 2025. As future editions create new unforgettable moments, this list will continue to grow and be updated along the way.
About Gaurav Sharma
I am the founder, lead writer, and editor behind Wrestling Nightmare. I have been analyzing and following professional wrestling for years, with a deep focus on WWE, AEW, and TNA—spanning the Attitude Era, the Ruthless Aggression transition, and modern long-term booking eras like The Bloodline. My work centers on breaking down in-ring storytelling, creative booking decisions, and the business landscape of combat sports entertainment. When I am not breaking down pay-per-view match structures, I am tracking roster movements, injury reports, and backstage creative pivots to deliver grounded, hype-free pro wrestling analysis.
contact@wrestlingnightmare.com
